Legal / Ethical

How Nurses Can Spot Signs of Human Trafficking

  • Human trafficking is a global crisis that impacts individuals regardless of age, race, ethnicity, sex, gender identity, immigration status, or socioeconomic status.   
  • Learn what human trafficking is and how to identify and support victims.
  • Victims of human trafficking are frequently seen by a healthcare provider while under the control of their trafficker. With proper training, nurses are well-positioned to identify victims of human trafficking and intervene appropriately. Your intervention may be both life-changing and lifesaving for human trafficking victims.  

      Angela McPhillips

      DNP, RN

      June 20, 2024
      Simmons University

      Imagine the following scenario: 

      You’re an ER nurse working the night shift at a Level 1 trauma center in Chicago. You pick up the following patient: a 21-year-old Hispanic, non-English speaking female. She presents with complaints of fever for two days, upper respiratory symptoms, and dehydration.   

      It is 2 a.m., and she is accompanied by her 2-year-old son and a middle-aged man who identifies as the patient’s uncle. The “uncle” speaks English and insists on translating for the patient. Per hospital policy, you request the services of an in-house Spanish-speaking interpreter.   

      The patient has difficulty maintaining eye contact with you and the interpreter, and she always looks at her uncle before answering any questions. You ask the uncle to leave as you help the patient change into a gown; he hesitantly leaves the room. 

      The interpreter remains with you as you continue to get a history from the patient. You ask about support at home since it is the middle of the night, and the 2-year-old is with the patient. She is evasive and replies that she does not have any family nearby.

      As you continue obtaining the history, the patient takes a long time to answer questions, and her answers about how long she has been sick and how she has been caring for herself at home do not quite add up. As the patient gets into her gown, you notice bruises in various stages of healing and a single tattoo on her wrist. You leave the room slightly unsettled as you prepare to start an IV, administer a fluid bolus, and perform a respiratory panel nasal swab, as you suspect she is flu positive.

      Do you spot any red flags? If you were this patient’s nurse, would you suspect her to be a victim of human trafficking? If you answered yes (or no), keep reading to learn how you could support this patient and bring awareness to human trafficking in your nursing practice and your healthcare institution.    

      Signs of human trafficking

      Human Trafficking: The Basics

      The US Department of Labor defines human trafficking as “a crime involving the exploitation of someone for the purposes of compelled labor or a commercial sex act through the use of force, fraud, or coercion.” 

      Human trafficking occurs globally, affecting an estimated 12 million to 30 million people. This includes more than 5 million children. Research suggests that 800,000 people are trafficked annually in the United States. Statistics are likely underreported because of this public health crisis’s secretive nature. As a nurse, there is a high likelihood that you will come into contact with a victim of human trafficking. 

      Traffickers often use the following tactics to lure victims into forced or coerced labor:

      • Violence  
      • Manipulation  
      • False promises of well-paying jobs  
      • Romantic relationships  

      Some victims of human trafficking might have initially consented to a working relationship with their trafficker but later found themselves in a situation against their will. Despite their initial consent, these individuals are victims. 

      Types of Human Trafficking

      Labor Trafficking: The U.S. Department of State explains that labor trafficking, or forced labor, involves the use of “force, fraud, or coercion to exploit the labor or services of another person.” Adults and children can be forced into labor.  

      This may involve:  

      • Forcing an individual to work for an employer while their trafficker collects the wages.  
      • Domestic servitude in which victims are forced to perform work in a private residence.   

      Human trafficking victims might be forced to work in various settings in seemingly ordinary roles, such as:  

      • Hospitality  
      • Agriculture  
      • Janitorial services  
      • Construction  
      • Landscaping  
      • Restaurants  
      • Factories  
      • Salon services  
      • Massage parlors  
      • Retail services  
      • Childcare  

      Sex Trafficking: Similar to labor trafficking, sex trafficking involves elements of coercion, force, or fraud that “compel another person to engage in a commercial sex act or causes a child to engage in a commercial sex act.”  

      Sex trafficking can take place in the following places:  

      • Private homes  
      • Massage parlors  
      • Hotels  
      • Brothels  
      • On the internet 

      Some individuals engage in commercial sex work as an informed choice. They are not victims of human trafficking; however, they can become victims if a trafficker takes control of their livelihood and forces them to engage in sex work against their will.   

      Who is at Risk? 

      Anyone can become a victim of human trafficking. However, specific characteristics or circumstances may increase the risk of becoming a victim.  

      Some risk factors are:  

      • Recent migration or relocation  
      • Language barriers  
      • Substance use  
      • Mental health concerns  
      • Physical or developmental disabilities  
      • Lack of social support systems  
      • Experiencing homelessness, being a runaway, or having experience in the child welfare system  

      Signs of human trafficking

      Recognize the Red Flags and Signs of Human Trafficking

      Be aware of these common indicators of human trafficking:  

      • Fearful, timid, submissive behavior
      • Bruises in various stages of healing  
      • Signs of being denied food, water, sleep, or medical care  
      • Juvenile engaged in commercial sex acts  
      • Disoriented, confused, or emotionally unstable  
      • Chronic body aches  
      • Recurrent sexually transmitted infections 
      • Reluctance to explain an injury  

      What Can You Do?  

       As a nurse, being aware of human trafficking is potentially lifesaving. The following measures can help you identify and support human trafficking victims: 

      • Speak with the patient alone.
      • Bring in a social worker or patient advocate.
      • Report suspected human trafficking to the proper authorities, such as federal law enforcement or the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
      • Post educational and support resources in discrete places, like the bathroom.
      • Coordinate care with other providers to ensure patients’ basic needs are met and a continuity of care (social worker, immigration services, law enforcement, emergency transitional shelter).

      Connect with leaders at your healthcare institution to provide system-wide human trafficking education and training.

      Resources and Support:

        Signs of human trafficking

      The Bottom Line

      Human trafficking is a highly prevalent health and human rights crisis. Nurses are well-positioned to identify and support victims of human trafficking. Bringing awareness of human trafficking to your healthcare institution will improve the health outcomes of human trafficking victims  

      Love what you read?
      Share our insider knowledge and tips!

      Read More